I consistently power down my cellphone upon entering a movie theater. Not simply on do not disturb – completely off. I mention this not because I'm superior, or in the hope that the ghost of a classic director will materialize to shake my hand. I view it as one of life's minor indulgences: for at least ninety minutes, I exist as completely disconnected. I leave my phone off throughout the scroll as well. It strikes me as indulgent to remain seated as other patrons trickle away, lit only by the scrolling names.
And, lately, by the light of the Letterboxd app.
Over millions of individuals engage with Letterboxd, a cinema-tracking app. Like the Criterion Collection, it has transformed into a marker for a particular kind of tastemaker who champions new releases and revels in revisiting vintage films. Members rate and review films, and the most insightful or most profound commentaries rise to prominence, encouraging cinephiles to craft thoughtful responses.
"Unless I jot down my ideas quickly once the movie ends, my critiques are much less lucid and well-put," remarked a student.
On a recent outing to the cinema, the credits had barely started before the gentleman ahead of me started composing his review. A few seats over, a couple lingered, looking down, jotting down their individual impressions.
The renowned film-maker David Lynch had a piece of guidance: write down every spark of inspiration the very second it occurs to you. Failing to do so, it could slip your mind, and, in his words: "Forgetting a good idea, you want to commit suicide." While Lynch spoke to aspiring film-makers, the same principle fits the act of reviewing.
Josh Stern, a young university attendee in New York, without fail writes his assessments while still in the cinema.
"Should I fail to articulate my impressions quickly after the credits roll, my critiques are much less lucid and well-put," he explained. "It requires a bit. I'm not a fast writer, and my significant other gets impatient."
Stern attends the movies often – 182 visits last year – and is on a friendly footing with the ushers, who at times have to ask him to leave so they can commence sweeping the aisles. He believes it perfectly fair to milk the end credits: "When you purchase a cinema ticket, the end titles constitute a portion of the movie."
Letterboxd's most passionate users credit the platform with reviving enthusiasm around a battered film industry, where output has decreased and unemployment is up. (Letterboxd also possesses the sort of demographics companies covet – its primary group of users is aged 18 and 24, with those aged 25 to 35.)
Excitement begets additional buzz; much-hyped movies experience a flurry of reviews on Letterboxd right after the premiere showtimes. The most-liked critique of a divisive adaptation – "Emily Brontë succumbed long ago yet this version is still the worst thing that has ever happened to her" – has garnered over 50,000 hearts. Another fictionalized retelling inspired this contrast to a major artist's concert film: "the Eras Tour documentary found dead."
"It's a little an addiction," commented Ben Glidden, a 33-year-old New Yorker who works in marketing. He also likes to compose critiques during the closing scroll. "Reflecting on what you just experienced, immediately after you experienced it, aids the artistic experience. It clarifies the central themes of a film. If it evokes a sensation of contentment, that's hardly something you recall hours later."
He feels most compelled to review a film if it was exceptionally good – or exceptionally bad. For example: he recently watched a big-budget project. "I was so appalled by how egregiously bad it was, that I was excited to whip out my phone and award it a lowest possible score," he noted. (He is a stricter critic than some film critics, who awarded the film three stars, describing it as "clever and engaging fare.")
Another user, a twenty-eight-year-old professional who manages social media, saw an acclaimed movie at a neighborhood theater and remained to write the write-up ("it received five stars"). He has clocked worse behavior: people pulling out their phones to log the movie they are actively viewing. "That behavior gets on my nerves," he admitted.
One of film's most persistent urban legends describes a showing of an 1896 motion picture that showed a train entering a station. The medium was in its infancy and – according to this debunked story – the footage of a locomotive moving right toward the camera shocked the spectators so much that people scattered in terror.
Many decades later, movie theater manners is just as poor. Often, individuals knows how to act in public any more, especially when the lights dim: patrons use their phones of the projection, smuggle in smelly food, and, as seen during a recent cinematic event, occasionally participate in fights.
A number of users have resorted to social media to debate the propriety of "Letterboxding" in the closing scroll. When one social media user